Synopsis Martin Scorsese's 1995 film Casino follows the life of Sam 'Ace' Rothstein (Robert De Niro) as he runs the mob-owned Tangiers casino. The movie also deals with his relationship with his friend Nicky Santoro (Joe Pesci) and the love of his life Ginger (Sharon Stone). Casino Script - Dialogue Transcript Voila! Finally, the Casino script is here for all you quotes spouting fans of the movie directed by Martin Scorsese and starring Joe Pesci, Sharon Stone, Kevin Pollak, James Woods, yadda yadda This script is a transcript that was painstakingly transcribed using the screenplay and/or viewings of Casino. Movie Scripts and Movie Screenplays. The Spirit of St. Louis - by Billy Wilder & Wendell Mayes january 8, 1957 final draft host info. Spitfire - by B. Nicholas Pileggi began working on the script for Casino, based on the Rosenthal family, with Martin Scorsese around 1990. Filming began in the fall of 1994, and the film was released a year later, in November 1995. Sharon Stone was cast to portray Geri McGee and was nominated for the Academy Award for Best Lead Actress for her performance. The movie Casino was a 1995 release directed by Martin Scorsese. It starred Robert De Niro, Joe Pesci and Sharon Stone. The plot was inspired by the real-life story of Frank “Lefty” Rosenthal who.
'Casino' is a historical mob drama chronicling the rise and fall of mafia involvement in the Las Vegas casino industry. Based on real events, 'Casino' is Nicholas Pileggi's adaptation of his own book, Casino: Love and Honor in Las Vegas (1995).
Two significant characters in 'Casino' are Latter-day Saints, or based partially on real-life Latter-day Saints. One character ('John Nance') is called an 'old Mormon' by Joe Pesci's character 'Nicky' approximately 8 minutes, 28 seconds after the start of the film. Another character ('Senator Harrison Roberts') is based partially on real-life Latter-day Saint politician Senator Harry Reid, who served as a Nevada state senator at the time period depicted in 'Casino,' and eventually became the Senate Minority Leader for the U.S. Senate.
The real-life mob figure Anthony 'Tony' Spilotro (who was portrayed in the film by Joe Pesci, using the name 'Nicky Santoro') had a girlfriend who was a Latter-day Saint. Her name was Sheryl, and her time with Tony Spilotro (i.e., 'Nicky Santoro') is described in Nicholas Pileggi's non-fiction book Casino: Love and Honor in Las Vegas. Sheryl was not included as a character in the film version of Casino.
'Casino' focuses on 'Sam 'Ace' Rothstein' (Robert De Niro), who is assigned by mafia bosses to head up a lucrative hotel and casino. Rothstein knows that money is skimmed from the profits of his casino and sent to the mafia bosses that backed the operation, but for the most part he runs a legitimate business and has no interest in hurting anybody. Rothstein's boyhood friend Nicky Santoro (Joe Pesci) is also part of the mafia, but comes to Las Vegas to make money through myriad ruthless, criminal methods, including extortion, burglary and murder.
Sharon Stone plays 'Ginger,' a beautiful grifter whose outgoing personality catches Rothstein's attention. Rothstein courts and marries Ginger, but theirs is a stormy relationship. Despite marriage to Rothstein, Ginger remains committed to low-life crook and parasite named 'Lester Diamond' (played by Vernal, Utah native James Woods). She also has an affair with her husband's friend Nicky. Sharon Stone received a Golden Globe award and an Academy Award nomination for her role. Acclaimed filmmaker Martin Scorsese received a Golden Globe nomination for Best Director for 'Casino.'
The name of the 'Senator' is never mentioned in the 'Casino' screenplay. The Senator's name is never spoken aloud in the film. But we know that the influential Senator character is named 'Harrison Roberts.' The Senator's name is shown prominently on a placard in front of him at the Senate Gaming Commission hearing at which Sam Rothstein's gaming license is revoked. The name of Senator 'Harrison Roberts' is intentionally similar to Senator Harry Reid's name. They share the same initials, and 'Harrison' would likely be called 'Harry' for short.
Ten years after 'Casino' was released, Sen. Harry Reid became the highest-ranking Democrat in the United States when he became the Senate Minority Leader. This also made Reid the highest-ranking elected Latter-day Saint in the U.S. federal government. (Mike Leavitt, another devout Latter-day Saint, concurrently held a Cabinet-level position as Secretary of Health and Human Services, but that is an appointed office.)
Another award-winning movie with a Harry Reid connection is Steven Soderbergh's Academy Award-winning movie about the U.S. drug war 'Traffic' (2000), in which Harry Reid makes a cameo appearance as himself, discussing policy with Michael Douglas in a Washington, D.C. reception. Senator Orrin Hatch, another high-ranking Latter-day Saint politician, appeared as himself in the same scene in 'Traffic.'
In an article by Chris Suellentrop, Slate reported (22 Dec. 2004, http://slate.msn.com/id/2111392/):
Reid may not be the most colorful figure in Washington, but his career is far more interesting than that of the average senator. In politics, Nevada is the next best thing to Louisiana. To take just one example, is there another U.S. senator who has been part of the inspiration for a character in a Martin Scorsese film? (A character played by Dick Smothers, no less.) In Casino, Robert DeNiro's character melts down in front of the Nevada Gaming Commission after the commission denies him a license to operate a casino. The scene is loosely based on a December 1978 hearing when Reid was the commission's chairman, and some of the dialogue spoken by Smothers is taken directly from Reid's words during the hearing. (The rest of the scenes involving Smothers, who plays a composite politician known only as 'Senator,' have nothing to do with Reid.) OK, it's lackluster Scorsese, but at least it's not Gangs of New York. And there are other Reid echoes in Casino: Joe Pesci's character refers to a 'Mr. Cleanface,' which gangster Joe Agosto said was his nickname for an in-his-pocket Reid, but a five-month investigation of Agosto's claims cleared Reid of wrongdoing.Note that although the actual hearing that the 'Casino' scene is based on took place in December 1978, the scene is set in 1980 in the movie.
Below the section from the 'Casino' screenplay in which Joe Pesci's character 'Nicky' refers to 'Mr. Clean Face,' which a gangster said was his nickname for Sen. Reid (line 7625). This passage does not appear to refer to the Senator in the screenplay.
In a column for Hot Boxing News ('Talkin' Boxin', 10 March 2003; URL: http://www.hotboxingnews.com/reed/reed030903.htm), Howie Reed wrote:
It should be noted that at one time Senator Reid was the Chairman of the State Gaming Commission. His tenure included the period of time featured in the movie Casino. On Federal Wiretaps some claim that his voice turns up in regard to the securing of a gaming license for the late Frank Sinatra. It is also alleged that the Dick Smothers role in Casino was drawn on the Chairmanship of Mr. Reid.A website called 'Choose Our President 2008' discusses potential presidential candidates for the 2008 race. The page analyzing Sen. Reid's chances as a Presidential hopeful mention 'Casino' (http://members.aol.com/ourprez08/reid.html):
Political pluses and minuses: Senator Reid was reelected in 2004 for his fourth term as senator from Nevada with a large margin, and is now the new top Democrat in the United States government, the public face of the opposition for the foreseeable future. Reid is moderate, deliberate and soft-spoken, with a reputation for integrity and bipartisanship. He fought the mob in Vegas during the seventies as chairman of the Nevada Gaming Commission, putting his life on the line (and is rumored to be the inspiration for Dick Smothers's character in Martin Scorsese's Casino). Reid has the advantage for the 2008 race of not having to run for reelection to the Senate, and has a new visibility and influence as Minority Leader. Not a Southern governor, Reid could nevertheless be a strong presidential or vice presidential candidate. He would be our first Mormon president or vice president, and our second named Harry.The Explore-Biography.com Dictionary of Famous People notes 'Casino' in its capsule biography of Sen. Harry Reid (http://www.explore-biography.com/religious_figures/H/Harry_Reid.html):Harry Mason Reid (born December 2, 1939) is the senior United States Senator from Nevada and a member of the Democratic Party, for which he serves as Minority Leader.
A Latter-day Saint and native of the small mining town of Searchlight, Nevada, his father was an alcoholic gold miner who committed suicide. Reid was a lawyer in the state before entering politics, serving a term in the Nevada state legislature and then being elected lieutenant governor in 1970. He served in that office until 1974.
Reid served as Nevada state gaming commissioner from 1977 to 1981, a post which subjected him to threats of danger. Reid's wife once found a bomb attached to one of their cars. A character in the film Casino played by Dick Smothers is based, in part, on Reid. Reid was also bribed by Jack Gordon (who would later manage and marry LaToya Jackson). Reid allowed the FBI to tape Gordon's attempt to bribe Reid with $12,000, at which point Reid attempted to strangle Gordon, saying 'You son of a bitch, you tried to bribe me.'
Reid was elected to the United States House of Representatives. He served two terms there, from 1983 to 1987, being reelected in 1984. He was elected to the Senate in 1986, succeeding the Republican incumbent, Paul Laxalt, who did not run in that election. Reid was reelected in 1992, 1998 and 2004. He narrowly defeated his Republican opponent in 1998, future Senator John Ensign (Ensign won Nevada's other Senate seat in 2000) and his Republican opponent in 2004 was Richard Ziser, whom Reid defeated by a vote of 61%-35%. Mike Ensign, Senator Ensign's father, contributed $2,000 to Reid's 2004 Senate campaign. In 1999, Reid became Minority Whip, and the right hand man of Minority Leader Tom Daschle of South Dakota
On November 16, 2004, Reid was elected Senate Democratic Leader and Minority Leader for the 109th Congress, following Daschle's defeat in his bid for reelection.
Some consider Harry Reid pro-life, or an opponent of legalized abortion, because of his vote against support of Roe v. Wade in 2004. However, Reid has subsequently refused to state he wants Roe v. Wade overturned. Reid is currently also the only Democratic Mormon Senator. Four other members in the Senate are members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, but they are all Republican.
As mentioned above, the Nevada state senator played by Dick Smothers in 'Casino' is known only as the SENATOR in the script. The Senator in 'Casino' is a composite character not intended purely as a depiction of Senator Harry Reid of Nevada. However, one scene is based losely on a December 1978 hearing which Reid presided over as chairman of the Nevada Gaming Commission. Some of the dialogue spoken by the Senator (as played by Dick Smothers) was taken directly from Reid's words during the hearing.Below is an excerpt from the screenplay featuring this scene (beginning at line 8838 of the 15,177-line script):
The scenes in 'Casino' which feature the Senator (including the scenes in the casino which were not based on real-life Latter-day Saint Senator Harry Reid) comprise 309 lines of the the 15,177-line script, or 2.0% of the length of the screenplay.
Now this old Mormon [EXPLETIVE] here, he had to fly in with suitcases once a month. Nice and easy.Nance (played by Bill Allison) is one of the key money men in the hotel's operations. Nance is what is known as a 'bagman.' Early in the movie (beginning 6 minutes, 21 seconds after the start of the film), John Nance is shown walking through the casino, going into the money-counting room, filling a suitcase with cash, flying to Kansas, and delivering the money to the mob bosses. The section ends 9 minutes, 31 seconds after the start of the film, meaning this section focusing on Nance is 3 minutes, 10 seconds long.
Nance appears in subsequent scenes, although he has few lines after this scene. Eventually Nance is killed by operatives working for Joe Pesci's character 'Nicky.'
It is not clear from the film if Joe Pesci means that Nance actually is a Mormon (a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints), or if Nance simply reminds Pesci of Mormons because of his clean-cut look and clean-living ways. Nance knowingly assists the mafia in skimming money from the casino, so obviously if he is a Latter-day Saint his work for the casino violates the 12th Article of Faith:
We believe in being subject to kings, presidents, rulers, and magistrates, in obeying, honoring, and sustaining the law.In doing research about the 'John Nance' character in 'Casino,' I could not find any information about an actual Las Vegas bagman or high-level casino operative by this name. It is entirely possible that the character is based on a real person, but the name seems to be entirely fictional.
Boston-born actor 'Jack Nance' (whose birth name was Marvin John Nance) has no connection to the 'John Nance' character in 'Casino.' Jack Nance was credited as 'John Nance' when he had the lead role ('Henry Spencer') in David Lynch's movie 'Eraserhead' (1977). Nance may be best known for his supporting role as 'Pete Martell' in Lynch's TV series 'Twin Peaks.' He also appeared in all of Lynch's movies after 'Eraserhead' (except for 'Elephant Man'), including: 'Lost Highway' (a 1997 movie which features a major character from Utah) and 'Blue Velvet' (1986). John Nance (or 'Jack Nance') the actor was born in 1943, so he would have been only 30 years old at the time his first scene in 'Casino' takes place: 1973. In that scene, Nance is clearly an older man, probably at least 60 years old. Moreover, John 'Jack' Nance spent his career as an actor, and did not work or live in Las Vegas. Clearly 'John Nance' in 'Casino' has no connection to the similarly-named actor.
Bill Allison, the actor who plays 'John Nance' in 'Casino' really does have a casino background. Allison owned the historic Mizpah hotel-casino in Tonopah for 16 years during the 1970s and 1980s. Bill Allison was originally hired as a consultant for the production of 'Casino,' but ended up being cast as an actor in the film as well. Bill Allison had no prior acting experience.
While Bill Allison's character 'John Nance' is called a 'Mormon' in the film, and he may indeed be intended by the writers to be a Latter-day Saint, actor Bill Allison is not known to be a Latter-day Saint.
Interestingly enough, Bill Allison subsequently played a casino guard in the Las Vegas casino movie 'Ocean's Eleven' (2001). Coincidentally, 'Ocean's Eleven' (2001) holds the record as the highest-grossing movie ever to feature main characters overtly identified as Latter-day Saints. One of Bill Allison's only other film roles aside from 'Casino' (in which Joe Pesci calls him a 'Mormon') and 'Ocean's Eleven' (in which he co-stars with two Mormon characters - Virgil and Turk Malloy) is the short film 'Courage & Stupidity' (2004), which was filmed in Salt Lake City. 'Courage & Stupidity' is a fictional comedy about what 'really' happened between a young Steven Spielberg (Todd Wall) and a young George Lucas (Aaron Fiore) during the filming of 'Jaws.' Bill Allison plays a movie producer in 'Courage & Stupidity.' Latter-day Saint actors in the film's cast include Johnny Biscuit ('Handcart', 'The Singles Ward') and Brian Sullivan. The film was written and directed by Utahn Darin Beckstead. The director of photography was Latter-day Saint cinematographer Brian Sullivan (Getting There; Little Secrets; Coyote Summer; The Paper Brigade; Wish Upon a Star; The Brainiacs.com; Just Like Dad; etc.) and special effects were by Ben Josephsen.
Aside from 'Casino,' 'Ocean's Eleven' and 'Courage & Stupidity,' the only other film role listed for Bill Allison on IMDb.com is a small part in 'Stuey' (2003), which was filmed partially in Las Vegas and has no known Latter-day Saint characters.
The character 'John Nance' is only overtly described as a 'Mormon' once in 'Casino' - in the section of the film in which he first appears. The character appears in many subsequent scenes. Nance really never does anything in the film that clearly indicates he is a Latter-day Saint. Nor does he ever do anything that clearly indicates he is not one (aside from the connection to the mafia that his job entails).
Below is an excerpt from the 'Casino' screenplay, featuring the scenes which follow Nance ('a Mormon,' according to Joe Pesci's character) as he brings money from the casino in Las Vegas to the operation's real backers in Kansas City. Although Nance has relatively few lines during this section, the camera focuses on him almost non-stop during these scenes.
6 minutes, 21 seconds after the start of the film:End of section above: 9 minutes, 31 seconds after the start of the film. This section focusing on Nance is 3 minutes, 10 seconds long.
About half-way through the screenplay (line 7086 of the 15,177-line script), Nance appears for the second time:
A minute later there is the third section featuring John Nance (line 7334 of the 15,177-line script):
Piscano (played by Vinny Vella) later mentions Nance (line 8328):
In the fourth section of the film featuring Nance, he is almost arrested by the FBI toward the end of the script (line 14,255 of the 15,177-line script):
Finally, the fifth section of 'Casino' to feature John Nance shows his gruesome death at the hands of men working for Nicky (Joe Pesci), after Nance has already left his life in Las Vegas behind and retired to Costa Rica (line 14,587 of the 15,177-line script):In total, the scenes featuring 'John Nance' comprise 556 lines in the 15,177-line script, or 3.7% of the length of the screenplay. John Nance is a relatively minor character in the movie.
The scenes in 'Casino' featuring the movie's two Latter-day Saint characters (or characters based on real-life Latter-day Saints) - 'John Nance' and 'the Senator' - comprise a total of 865 lines, or 5.7% of the length of the screenplay.
Source: Nicholas Pileggi. Casino: Love and Honor in Las Vegas. New York: Simon & Schuster (1995).
Nicholas Pileggi's non-fiction book Casino: Love and Honor in Las Vegas is (according to the book jacket):
...a riveting, true-life story of love and death in Las Vegas, a fatal romantic love triangle betweenPages 154 to 158:
As time passed, Spilotro spent less and less time with his wife, Nancy. When they were together, they fought -- and the FBI listened. She complained that he had lost interest in her. She accused him of affairs. He was never home. He never talked to her. In the morning, the FBI recorded the sound of silence as Tony made his coffee and Nancy read the newspaper. Then he would leave for the store without even saying good-bye.Sometimes Nancy had to call him at work to relay a message; according to Bud Hall, Tony was always rude. 'She'd say, 'I don't know if this can wait, but so-and-so called.' 'It can wait,' Tony would say, sort of sarcastically, and just hang up. Or he'd say, in an exasperated tone, 'Nancy, I'm busy,' and hang up. He was never gentlemanly with her, and she'd whine to Dena Harte, Herbie Blitzstein's girlfriend, who managed the front of the Gold Rush. Nancy would tell Dena whenever Tony beat her up or whenever she suspected Tony was fooling around with this one or that one, and Dena kept Nancy informed about what Tony was doing.
'There was one time when Dena called Nancy at home and said, 'The bitch is here.' Nancy jumped in the car and tore over to the place and started screaming at Sheryl, Tony's girlfriend, calling her a no-good [EXPLETIVE] right there in the middle of the store.
'We could hear the screaming on the wire, and then Tony comes out, and then we hear Nancy screaming for Tony to stop hitting her. He was really beating her up. We got worried that he was going to kill her. It was a mess. So we called nine-one-one and said we were in the Black Forest German Restaurant next door, and said someone was being assaulted in the Gold Rush. We couldn't tell the cops who we were because at that point it looked like Tony owned Metro, and we didn't want to blow our surveillance. The police got there in a few minutes, and everything calmed down.'
'Nancy had her life and Tony had his,' said Frank Cullotta. 'Hers was mostly playing tennis and running around in white outfits. She had Vincent and Tony's brothers and their families. Once a week Tony'd take her out to dinner or something. But she wasn't afraid of him. She would scream and yell at him and drive him crazy.
'Once, he told me, she tried to kill him. They were having an argument over something and Tony knocked her across the room. She came up with a loaded thirty-eight cocked at his head. 'I'll kill you if you ever hit me again,' she said. Tony said, 'Nancy, think of Vincent.'
'I saw death,' he told me after. 'We talked until she put down the gun and then I hid all the guns in the house.'
'Sheryl was about twenty, but she looked younger,' said Rosa Rojas, who was her best friend. 'She was a Mormon from northern Utah, cute and fresh. When Tony first met her he used to call her his country girl. She was so naive that when he asked her out, she said she'd only go if she could bring her friend.
'Sheryl and I were both working in the hospital where he was going for his heart problem, which was how they met. They'd go to restaurants, but he never put the make on her. He held her at a distance for a long, long time.
Before he got too close he found out everything there was to find out about her. He had Joey Cusumano ask about where she was from, who her friends were, how long she lived where she lived. He wanted to know everything he could know about her before he got involved or felt he could trust her.
'It was a long time before she knew who he was. She began to suspect something was strange, because every time they went out, they were tailed by cops in plain clothes. Tony's brother told her that there were some legal problems and that Tony was being trailed because of the legal stuff. Tony used to tell us that we were going to read things about him in the newspapers, but he said the newspapers weren't always right.
'It was only after a long time that Tony and Sheryl started going to bed together. He was a gentleman always. Very quiet. Very reserved. I would see him mad sometimes, but I never once heard him curse or use bad language.
'Eventually, he bought her a two-story condo around Eastern and Flamingo, a two-bedroom place for about sixty-nine thousand dollars. It had everything. Refrigerator. Blinds. A washer-dryer. There was a garage and small patio and a sliding door that led into the downstairs, and upstairs they had the bedrooms and a large room that had all of the stereo and TV equipment you would want. That's where they spent most of their time -- watching ball games and listening to music.
'Tony was very generous. He used to leave a thousand dollars a week in a bear-shaped cookie jar in the kitchen. He never mentioned money and it was never mentioned that he was keeping her, but when he bought her a full-length mink coat Sheryl felt he had finally committed himself to her. She had really fallen in love with him.
'She didn't know he was married for quite a while. When she found out, it was very hard. She believed the only reason she and Tony weren't married was because Tony was a very strict Catholic and would have trouble leaving his wife. For a while, Tony even had Sheryl learning to be a Catholic. He gave her religious books to read. He knew the Bible.
'He never ever said anything bad about his wife. They had been married in the church and it was a difficult situation. On top of that. Tony loved his son. Vincent meant everything to him. Vincent was his soul. Tony would always get home at six thirty in the morning so he could be there to make breakfast for Vincent. Sheryl said he would do that even if he was in bed at her place.
'Eventually, Tony bought a car for her. It was a new Plymouth Fury. It wasn't a showy car.
'When Nancy found out what was going on, things got a little tough. Sheryl had stopped by the Gold Rush to see Tony. She was wearing a diamond studded S necklace that Tony had given her, and when Nancy came in and saw Sheryl wearing the S necklace. Nancy went wild and she reached for it.
'I got there just at that time and I found the two of them wrestling on the floor. Sheryl managed to hold on to her S. Tony came out of the back room and broke up the fight so Sheryl and I could get away.
'In the end, when it was over between Tony and Sheryl, he wouldn't return her calls. Sheryl was really crazy about him, but maybe she pushed too hard. He was having a lot of problems with the cops when they broke up, and maybe he was trying to spare her.
'His brother John used to tell her not to try and reach him. 'Don't call him,' he'd say. 'Spare yourself.' But she'd see him making his court appearances on TV and she saw that he was gaining weight and didn't look good, and she used to blame Nancy for not taking care of him. Sheryl used to make sure he ate the right food, and her refrigerator was always filled with fruits and salad and the kinds of healthy food that were good for people with heart problems.
'After she and Tony broke up she got a job doing cocktails at night. Tony wasn't happy about it. But she had grown accustomed to his lifestyle. She needed the money. Then she got into dealing blackjack. She worked in the old MGM, at Rally's. She had a prime shift and made excellent money. She started meeting high rollers. She wised up. She learned and started looking around for another rock to stand on.'
One part of the 'Casino' non-fiction book that is interesting is the description of Sheryl's effect on hard-bitten mob muscleman Tony Spilotro:
He was a gentleman always. Very quiet. Very reserved. I would see him mad sometimes, but I never once heard him curse or use bad language.This is NOT the way that Tony acted most of the time, according to the book. If you have seen 'Casino' the movie, you know that 'never once heard him curse or use bad language' is NOT how Joe Pesci portrays the character of Tony Spilotro (i.e., Nicky Santoro). Joe Pesci's character may be the foulest-mouthed character in the movie, and may be one of the foulest-mouthed characters Joe Pesci has played in any movie (which is saying something). It's nice to think that his Mormon girlfriend didn't put up with that kind of language.
Another interesting passage indicates that Sheryl's background as a Latter-day Saint (or perhaps her training as a nurse) had a healthful effect on Tony's life, as she encouraged him to eat according to the Word of Wisdom:
Sheryl used to make sure he ate the right food, and her refrigerator was always filled with fruits and salad and the kinds of healthy food that were good for people with heart problems.Trivia Footnote about the name 'Nicky Santoro':
Ace Rothstein (Robert De Niro) is surrounded by the press at a Nevada Gaming Commission meeting portrayed in Casino. Rothstein’s lawyer, Oscar Goodman (played by Goodman himself), stands by his side. Photo courtesy of Oscar Goodman.
Though the movie Casino was released more than 22 years ago, it still serves as a reference point for those hoping to understand what real Las Vegas mobsters were like when they were a sinister fixture in the news.
But most movies based on true stories, including Casino, twist the facts for dramatic effect and to compress long histories into a watchable timeframe.
What you see in Casino isn’t exactly the way things were. Case in point: the death of the Spilotro brothers, two mobsters originally from Chicago.
The way the movie portrays it, the brothers — or at least the fictional characters representing Anthony and Michael Spilotro — are beaten with baseball bats in a cornfield and shoved into a shallow grave while still alive.
Not true.
In his 2009 book Family Secrets: The Case That Crippled the Chicago Mob, journalist Jeff Coen details what really happened. Coen covered the Family Secrets trial for the Chicago Tribune. That 2007 trial resulted in convictions and revealed details that weren’t publicly known when the movie came out more than a decade earlier.
In the 1995 movie, it was baseball bats in a cornfield. But according to trial testimony, the Spilotros were lured to a residence near O’Hare International Airport in Bensenville, a subdivision of “modest homes,” and were beaten to death in the basement. (At the trial, one of the killers, Mob turncoat Nick Calabrese, said he could not recall which house it was.)
Anthony and his brother, Michael, a part-time actor and owner of the Chicago restaurant and Mob hangout Hoagie’s, went to the home in June 1986 believing they were to be promoted within the Outfit.
Although the brothers were suspicious, refusing to go was unthinkable.
When the Spilotros got to the basement, about 15 mobsters pounced on them. Michael had brought a pocket-sized .22-caliber handgun but could not get to it. Anthony was heard asking if he could say a prayer but was swarmed.
In addition to breaking Michael’s nose, the attackers inflicted blunt force injuries over his entire body. They severely bruised Anthony’s face, left temple and chest.
Anthony, 48, had blood in his trachea, lungs and nasal passages and hemorrhaging in the muscles of the larynx. The 41-year-old Michael had a fractured Adam’s apple.
Neither man’s skin was broken, indicating the killers did not use a heavy object such as a baseball bat. The brothers were beaten with fists, knees and feet, according to a pathologist at the trial.
The Spilotros were dead when buried in an Enos, Indiana, cornfield about 100 miles south of the murder house. The brothers were placed in a five-foot grave in only their underwear, one on top of the other.
The cornfield is near land that Outfit boss Joseph “Joey Doves” Aiuppa used for hunting, according to Coen. A farmer discovered the grave, thinking someone had buried a deer. The Spilotros were identified by dental X-rays provided by a third bother, Patrick Spilotro, a dentist.
Why did this happen to Anthony and Michael Spilotro? Mob higher-ups felt the two had to be silenced.
Since the early 1970s, Anthony Spilotro had overseen street rackets in Las Vegas for the Chicago Outfit. He also was keeping an eye on Frank “Lefty” Rosenthal, a Chicago bookie handling the skim in Las Vegas for Midwestern Mob bosses.
Ultimately, though, news stories about Spilotro’s violent criminal activities, and his affair with Rosenthal’s wife, a former showgirl at the Tropicana hotel-casino, led to the gruesome outcome in that Bensenville basement.
Anthony Spilotro’s high-profile legal problems were jeopardizing the Outfit’s Las Vegas cash cow, prompting Aiuppa to order him “knocked down.” Michael Spilotro, facing a trial on extortion charges, had to go, too.
That terrifying outcome is not the only place where Casino misses the mark factually. In another example among many from the film, an animated Kansas City mobster pops off in an Italian grocery about the Las Vegas skim while federal authorities listen to his profanity-laced rant through a bug planted in a vent.
In reality, law enforcement authorities learned about the Las Vegas skim while eavesdropping on a conversation between members of the Civella crime family at a bugged back table in Kansas City’s Villa Capri pizzeria. Unlike the movie, there was no humorous scolding mom at the now-demolished Villa Capri nagging her mobster son about his vulgar language.
The only ones at the table were sinister Mob figures, behaving like real-life conspiratorial gangsters, not colorful movie characters.
Larry Henry is a veteran print and broadcast journalist. He served as press secretary for Nevada Governor Bob Miller, and was political editor at the Las Vegas Sun and managing editor at KFSM-TV, the CBS affiliate in Northwest Arkansas. Henry taught journalism at Haas Hall Academy in Bentonville, Arkansas, and now is the headmaster at the school’s campus in Rogers, Arkansas. The Mob in Pop Culture blog appears monthly.